Document Type : Original Article
1 Parasitology Departement, Fakultas Kedokteran Universitas Hang Tuah, Surabaya, Jawa Timur Indonesia
2 Internal Medicine Departement, Fakultas Kedokteran Universitas Hang Tuah – RSPAL Dr. Ramelan, Surabaya, Jawa Timur Indonesia
3 Anatomy Departement Fakultas Kedokteran Universitas Hang Tuah, Surabaya, Jawa Timur Indonesia
Background: Malaria resistance to artemisinin combination therapy has prompted researchers to explore anti-plasmodium materials. One of the marine biotas thought to have the potential to inhibit the development of malaria parasites (Plasmodium sp) are black trepang and curryfish. These two marine biotas consist of two varieties of sea cucumbers with various therapeutic benefits. However, their antimalarial effects have not been studied.
Objective: Two marine biotas, black trepang and curryfish extract, were analyzed using in vitro screening to determine their antimalarial activity.
Methods: The experiment was done through in vitro screening technique (culture medium containing P. falciparum). P1 was a negative control; P2 was a positive control/using chloroquine as an antimalarial; P3 was a group that received black trepang extract) and P4 was a group that received curryfish extract. Measurements of parasitemia levels, growth percentage, inhibition rate, and IC50 were performed to determine the antimalarial activity.
Results: The antimalarial results suggest that increasing the dose of marine biota extract reduces the parasite development rate and increases the inhibition rate. In line with IC50 analysis, both marine biotas have high antimalarial activity. Curryfish extract has a lower IC50 value than black trepang extract.
Conclusion: The study demonstrated that black trepang and curry fish have high antimalarial activity.
Malaria is a global epidemic that can be lethal, especially for high-risk individuals including babies, toddlers, and expectant mothers. Likewise, malaria contributes directly to anemia and can decrease labour performance. Malaria eradication has resulted in a decrease in morbidity and mortality . Still, malaria control efforts over the last decade have been ineffective . Malaria control is made worse by the COVID-19 pandemic, which affects the decline and slowdown of care for this infectious disease. This condition increased morbidity rates of 240 million cases and a mortality rate of around 627 thousand [2, 3].
During the last 20 years, artemisinin combination treatment, or ACT, has been the main medication for treating various malaria infections. Nevertheless, cases of ACT resistance have been reported in the Southeast Asian region . Even the most recent reports indicate that ACT resistance has occurred on the African continent in Rwanda  and Northern Uganda . Malaria eradication efforts are in jeopardy if ACT activity declines. Finding novel therapeutic strategies has become vitally critical in the fight against the emergence of ACT-resistant parasites.
The waters comprise 2/3 of the planet's surface and are habitat to diverse aquatic species. Numerous active substances with therapeutic effects are present in marine life. A significant increase in phylogenetic diversity is among the benefits of marine biota over land biota. The phylogenetic diversity is brought by various environmental stimulations, necessitating various adaptations and enabling the marine biota to produce unique active compounds with therapeutic value .
Curryfish (Latin name: Sticophus hermanni) is a type of sea cucumber found in shallow water and coral reefs . Little black or dark brown papillae strewn across both the lateral and dorsal sides, as well as its light yellow or green yellow coloring, are its distinguishing features . Curryfish has several active compounds such as glycosaminoglycans, keratin, glucosamine, triterpene glycoside, carotenoids, peptides, fatty acids, a natural antiseptic, minerals, omega 3 and 6, lectins, mucopolysaccharides, glycosides, chondroitin, cell growth factors, and collagen . According to the prior studies, curryfish's phytochemical assay contains various active molecules including terpenoid, tannin, steroid, saponin, and also flavonoid . The black trepang or brown trepang (Holothuria atra) is a reddish black sea cucumber with small and dense long papillae covering its dorsal surface. These sea cucumbers are found in all shallow waters of Indonesia, especially near sandy beach areas and coral reefs . Previous research has shown that black trepang phytochemical analysis contains various active compounds, including alkaloid, flavonoid, phenol hydroquinone, glycosides, saponins, steroid, and triterpenoids [13, 14]. Several active ingredients include triterpenoids , alkaloids, flavonoids, phenol, and saponin have antimicrobial properties .
Black trepang and curryfish become part of the community's nutrition and have been shown to contain various active substances with antifungal and antibacterial properties [16, 17]. Previously, the ability of Holothuria athra or black trepang to act as an antimalarial was investigated using an in silico method against the P. falciparum orotidine 5-monophosphate decarboxylase (PfOMPDC) protein . Research conducted in silico on curryfish's antimalarial properties further revealed that it inhibits glucose metabolism via Plasmodium falciparum hexose transporter (PfHT1) . However, no previous in vitro studies have been conducted comparing the antimalarial activity of the two species. The phenomenon of ACT resistance, increased malaria mortality-morbidity, bioactive components in sea cucumbers, and no in vitro study has been conducted to compare the antimalarial activity of two marine cucumber species, initiated research on the antimalarial properties of extracts from black trepang and curryfish. Utilizing marine biotas, such as black trepang and curryfish can be used as an alternative treatment to counter malaria drug resistance. This study evaluated curryfish and black trepang extracts' antimalarial potency against P.falciparum, using in vitro approach. Sea cucumber research and development should be continued to produce antimalarials that are effective but have few side effects.
Materials and Methods
The research design was a true experimental study that compared the experimental group and control group and observed the possibility of causation between both groups. The true experimental research methodology employed is a posttest-only control group design, in which the impact of treatment administration is measured at the end of the research. The research sample was P. falciparum culture medium. Each medium had the same amount of parasitemia, and the medium sample was distributed randomly among the research groups. The total number sample of this research was 40 sample mediums, which were divided into four groups:
P1: Negative control group, P.falciparum medium without administration of medicine or any extract.
P2: Positive control group, P.falciparum medium with antimalarial drug (chloroquine) administration.
P3: P.falciparum medium with the administration of black trepang extract.
P4: P.falciparum medium with the administration of curryfish extract.
P2-P4 groups will be given graded doses extract/drug, including 0.01, 0.1, 1, 10, and 100 µg/ml . Each type of dose will be administered to two culture medium samples in each group. The treatment description in this study can be seen in the following scheme (Figure 1):
The Ethics Committee of Hang Tuah Medical Faculty has given its official approval for the research's implementation. All phases of this research, including materials and in vitro testing, were carried out at Airlangga University's Malaria Laboratory - Tropical Disease Institute.
Black trepang and curryfish material
During the rainy season, the marine materials used in this study (black trepang and curryfish) were collected from the sea area near Sapeken Island, Sumenep, Madura-East Java, Indonesia. Taxonomic tests were performed on fresh black trepang and curryfish at the Plant Bioscience and Technology Laboratory, Institut Teknologi Sepuluh November, Surabaya, Indonesia.
The maceration or cold extraction technique is advantageous for this study in several ways. The inexpensive cost, more active components dissolve, a lot of extracts are produced, and the technique does not require heating, which lowers the chance that the ingredients will be broken down [21, 22].
The extraction process began with removing all internal organs from the meat and dried in a -50 °C freeze dryer. After drying, the meat of black trepang and curryfish is crushed into a powder (1 kg of wet black trepang and curryfish yield approximately 900 grams of powder). The sea cucumber powder was macerated with n-hexane solvent three times for twenty-four hours at room temperature, and then filtered through filter paper. The raw extract is obtained by rotating evaporating the resultant macerate at 60 °C. The raw extracts were kept refrigerated until needed in an airtight container [21, 22].
In vitro formation of plasmodium falciparum
Three fundamental components must be used for the culture technique: (1) Human blood plasma and packed red blood cells provided by the Red Cross, (2) Strain of P.falciparum, which is sensitive to chloroquine, and (3) medium RPMI 1640. This study conducted an in vitro experiment using a modified Trager and Jensen methodology . The first stage was initiated by dissolving 50 g/mL hypoxanthine, 5.94 g HEPES, and clean water in a beaker glass and stirring until homogeneous. To make 1 liter of solution, 10.4 g of RPMI-1640 or Roswell Park Memorial Institute 1640 media and clean water were added. The mixture was then supplemented with 2 mg/mL sodium bicarbonate (NaHCO3), 5.94 g/L HEPES or N-2-hydroxyethyl piperazine-N-2-ethane sulfonic acid, 25 mg gentamicin, and 10% serum from human blood [24, 25].
The screening of antimalarial activity
500 µl of parasite cell suspension (with 1% parasitemia level and 5% hematocrit) was placed into a 24-well microplate. With 5% sorbitol, the parasites remained kept in their ring-stage phase. 10 mg of chloroquine diphosphate (used as a positive control) and of black trepang - curryfish extracts were diluted in 1 mL of the solvent dimethyl sulfoxide or DMSO, which was then serially diluted using RPMI-1640 to make several concentrations (0.01, 0.1, 1, 10, and 100 g/mL) [24, 25]. DMSO was further employed as the negative control. The following step is to incubate the parasite culture media in a candle jar for two days at 37 °C, 5% CO2, 5 % O2, 90 % N2, and 95% humidity . The density of P. falciparum parasites was observed three times (n=3) by microscopic examination of thin peripheral blood smear stained with Giemsa and treated with methanol. A light microscope was used to examine the infected erythrocytes at 1000-fold magnification. The homogenized ring-stage P. falciparum parasites was used with a parasitemia density of about 1 percent [25, 27]. The parasitemia levels were rechecked after the two-day incubation period to assess the growth rate and degree of inhibition rate. This dataset was used to evaluate the parasitemia growth and inhibition rate (Figure 2).
The third step to evaluate the antimalarial activity of the extract was IC50. Inhibitory Concentration 50 or IC50 is a method for assessing the potency of a drug or active ingredient. In pharmacological research, the IC50 number calculates the drug/active ingredient required to reduce living organisms to 50%. In addition, Probit statistical analysis was used to calculate the IC50 [28, 29].
Antimalarial activity assessment standard
Based on their IC50 values, the extract substances were divided into four groups and evaluated by comparison to the WHO guidance and standard criteria for antimalarial drug research activities (Figure 3).
Research data analysis
The research analysis is divided into two stages:
(1) Importing all datasets into Excel, including parasitemia level, parasite growth percentage, and parasite inhibition percentage, and
(2) Entering all relevant data, such as parasitemia level, parasite growth percentage, and parasite inhibition percentage, into SPSS for probit regression analysis to determine the IC50. The probit analysis in this study assesses the drug concentration of black trepang and curryfish extract required to inhibit 50% of parasites [28, 29].
Results and Discussion
Evaluation of parasite growth percentage
The data below shows the results of the parasite growth after 48 hours of incubation (Table 1). All groups had homogeneous levels of parasitemia before incubation (parasitemia levels in all groups were 1.03%). The parasite growth (%) calculated by subtraction of parasitemia levels following black trepang and curryfish extract administration as well as parasitemia levels before the extract administration.
According to the statistics presented in Table 1, the mean result of the percentage of parasite growth indicates that a decrease will follow the increase in the chloroquine dose and extract in parasite growth. The parasite growth rate at P2 (positive control) in all quantities was lower than in the group receiving black trepang and curryfish extracts. In P2, it was not necessary to measure the parasite growth at a dose of chloroquine of 100 µg/mL because the development at a dose lower than it (dose 10 µg/ml) showed a very low growth rate, making it unnecessary to measure again at the subsequent dose. The percentage of parasite growth at P4 was lower than in P3. Furthermore, the percentage of parasite growth at P3 was lower at 10 g/mL extract than at P4.
Evaluation of inhibition rate percentage and IC50
An active ingredient's ability to stop an organism's growth is called inhibitory rate percentage. The formula for calculating the inhibitory rate can be seen in (Figure 2). The probit regression analysis method calculated the IC50 based on parasite growth and inhibitory rate information. The information in (Table 2) indicates the results of measuring the inhibitory rate (%) and inhibitory concentration 50 (IC50). As it can be seen in (Table 2), an increase in the drug's dose/ extract seems to increase the inhibitory rate. At 100 µg/mL extract doses, the maximum inhibitory rates were seen at P3 and P4. No calculation was made for the P2 inhibitory rate at a 100 µg/mL drug dose because the growth rate data was also not computed. Since no drugs or extracts were administered in P1, no data on calculating the inhibitory rate was available. The inhibitory rate at P4 was higher than at P3 (extract's dose 0.01 until 10 µg/mL).
However, the data revealed that both groups' inhibitory rates were the same at 100 µg/mL extracts. The IC50 data shows the dose of active ingredient that can suppress parasite growth by 50%, so when the IC50 number is lower, the antimalarial activity increases. P2 has the lowest IC50, followed by P4, and finally P3.
The research data revealed high antimalarial activity in black trepang and curryfish extract, based on parasite growth parameters, inhibitory rate, and IC50 measurement. According to the WHO guidelines for pharmacological research, a substance If its IC50 value falls below or equal to 5 g/ml, it is classified as a strong antimalarial . Black trepang's IC50 (1.23 µg/mL) was higher than curryfish's IC50 (1.07 µg/mL), which means curryfish has higher potency in reducing parasite development than black trepang. This research was an in vitro study. Therefore, all external and internal elements may be controlled, resulting in uniform conditions in each medium with a limited response to infection. The effect of administering the extract is more visible under homogenous research conditions and narrow responses. Adding the extract dose will increase the extract’s working activity. The activity improvement was probably due to an increase in active substance concentration, which is in line with increased extract dosages. That is, when an extract's active component content is higher, its antimalarial activity increases. There is a difference in the ability to impede rate between the two marine biotas due to variations in the composition and concentration of bioactive substances, which affect the antimalarial efficacy. Different IC50 values were found for the two marine biotas in this study. Still, because both had IC50 values were less than 5 µg/mL, they had the potent antimalarial activity.
Chloroquine, on the other hand, has a lower IC50 than the other two marine biotas. The P2 (positive control group that received chloroquine as antimalarial) had the lowest IC50 value in this study, indicating that chloroquine has the most significant action. Chloroquine's highest activity was possible because the strain of P. falciparum used in this experiment was chloroquine susceptible.
The anti-plasmodial activity of black trepang and curryfish is associated with various active ingredients such as flavonoids, triterpenoids, alkaloids, saponins, and tannin. These active ingredients have antimicrobial properties, which can reduce parasite growth through many pathways [13-15]. An earlier study demonstrated that the flavonoid components interact strongly with the falcipain-2 receptors. Falcipain-2 was a cysteine proteolytic enzyme identified in the Plasmodium feeding vacuole and plays a significant role in the hemoglobin degradation pathway. At the erythrocytic stage of P. falciparum, hemoglobin had to be degraded to produce amino acids. Inhibition of falcipain-2 function causes the accumulation of non-degradable hemoglobin in food vacuoles . In vivo study found that flavonoids are easily transformed into radical anions under a cellular oxidative stress environment, which severely induces the destruction of proteins, RNA, and DNA .
Several in vitro studies found derivatives of triterpenoids to have antimalarial activity. Unfortunately, the precise mechanism of action is currently unexplained. The possible mechanism of triterpenoids as antimalarial action includes their impacts on mitochondrial membrane potential and the reduction of β-haematin synthesis [31-33]. Triterpenoid (betulinic acid) antimalarial activity is assumed to be related to its ability to engage the PfATP6 protein, which regulates calcium ion transportation and affects the host-parasite selectivity .
Several alkaloid compounds have been demonstrated in vitro to have significant antimalarial action. A low IC50 value indicates that the antimalarial activity is significant . However, some derivatives are highly toxic, while others are unknown in terms of toxicity. Alkaloids' mechanisms of action have also not been investigated, so more research is required to determine the alkaloids pathway [37, 38]. The experimental studies in mice have demonstrated the antimalarial activity of saponin derivatives by inducing oxidative stress, which causes cell and tissue damage [39, 40]. According to review studies, saponin derivatives can act as antimalarial with low toxicity. Saponins derivatives may inhibit parasite development through three mechanisms, including (1) induced disorganization of membrane lipid raft, (2) inhibition of HMGB1 (high mobility group box 1) is a protein that affects the transcription process, and (3) potential inhibition of the detoxifying enzyme glyoxalase . Tannins are bioactive substances with antimalarial properties and an unknown action mechanism . However, tannins may have the ability to induce the crystallization of hemozoin pigment (a byproduct of hemoglobin metabolism) as well as inhibit protein biosynthesis and nucleic acid fragmentation [42, 43].
According to the findings of this study, all the active bioactive compounds should be determined using liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LCMS) on both marine biotas. We should do in vivo studies involving animal models to ascertain the antimalarial activity, the most effective preparations and solvents for the extraction process, the mode of action of the extracts, and the extract's effects on other tissue, such as the liver, spleen, and kidneys. A thorough investigation of the antimalarial activity of black trepang and curryfish is expected to be a breakthrough in discovering a new regimen for malaria based on a natural product and the minimum side effects.
The outcomes of this study show that black trepang and curryfish have significant antimalarial efficacy. Although the IC50 of curryfish is smaller than that of black trepang, both fulfill the WHO standards as active substances with high antimalarial potential. More research into curryfish and black trepang can be done by employing malaria mice models to ascertain their antimalarial action, immunological regulators, and reduced oxidative stress.
The authors acknowledges their appreciation for the financial assistance offered by the Medical Faculty of Hang Tuah University and LPPM of Hang Tuah University. The Ethics Committee of Hang Tuah Medical Faculty has permitted the experiment process. The Institute of Tropical Diseases Laboratory Airlangga University aids in all research processes.
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.
This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
All authors contributed to data analysis, drafting, and revising of the paper and agreed to be responsible for all the aspects of this work.
Prawesty Diah Utami
HOW TO CITE THIS ARTICLE
Prawesty Diah Utami, M. Fathi Ilmawan, Herin Setianingsih. Comparing Black Trepang and Curryfish Extract's Antimalarial Activity Using In Vitro Screening. J. Med. Chem. Sci., 2023, 6(9) 2085-2095